Visualising the Election

Chris Knox

Visualising the Election at the New Zealand Herald

An overview of:

  • Visualisation Requirements
  • Visualisation Engineering
  • Visualisation Design
  • Visualisation Implementation

Caveats

  • Opinions are my own
  • Please don't attribute anything I say here to me or the New Zealand Herald

Let's look at the actual visualisations

Two homepage elements

Summary with Ticker

summary ticker

Parliament view for the homepage

parliament

A big data article

An Electorate Tilemap

tilemap

Who's in and Who's Out?

whos in whos out

Detailled Parliament

detailled parliament

Visualisation Requirements

  • What is the first thing readers want to know?

Who's winning?

But what does winning look like under MMP/a system that creates coalitions?

Our 2017 visualisations didn't do enough to make it explicit that although National had the most votes it didn't mean they automatically formed a government.

Let's create a coalition builder

There was no coalition builder

We started on it but based on the polls took a gamble and decided not to build it.

Hot Take

MMP makes for (mostly) boring election visualisations

All you need is this

summary

(This is probably a sign of a good electoral system)

  • We did discuss creating more of a visualisation but it was decided that what most readers wanted to see first was just how each party was doing.

So what are the requirements?

  • Quick summary
  • Everything on mobile
  • Fast(est) results
  • What do the results mean?

  • Automatically updating visualisations
  • Support hundreds of thousands of readers
  • Visual overview of electorate results
  • Ability to explore electorate results

Engineering election night visualisations

Data source

The Electoral Commission provides the data as XML

  • We don't want to send that XML to our readers
    • I don't want to parse XML in javscript
    • The Electoral Commission doesn't want us to connect thousands of readers to their servers

Server load

  • We need to support hundreds of thousands of readers and then essentially nothing
  • We also want to minimise our bandwidth bill

I reckon the only (sensible) way to do this is push everything to a CDN

  • Code runs on a server and converts XML into JSON and CSV and then writes this to AWS S3 buckets
  • Data is served from S3 via a CDN
  • Large data files are cached (for a month)
    • this stops readers downloading files they already have
    • this reduces the cost of S3 -> CDN transfers
  • Small files are not cached
  • A small index file is used to point to the latest results
    • Client-side code downloaded these files every 30 seconds (until midnight)

Aside: Choice of programming language

7pm on election night is very stressful

Haskell

  • Haskell is fast(ish)
  • The Electoral Commision also provides high quality DTD files along with their XML files
  • Using Haskell and the DTD files it is relatively easy to encapsulate the entire state of the system in code so that all possible scenarios are handled
    • This isn't true of Python

Designing Election Visualisations

Maps

New Zealand Electoral geography is a pain

  • New Zealand Electorates are designed to each contain roughly the same population
  • Lots of New Zealand is sparsely populated
  • Historically rural electorates have voted differently to urban ones

2017 Electorate Results
National's 41 versus Labour's 29

Credit: TVNZ

Tilemaps

Each electorate has the same population so each electorate should take the same area on a map

Hexes or Squares

  • Hex based tilemaps are quite common for election results and have been used well in the UK and Germany
  • Chris McDowell tried an NZ electorate tilemap

hexmap

Chris was not happy with it.

It also won't be great on mobile.

Squares work better for New Zealand

squares

Especially when there are 72 electorates!

squares in a grid

Building a Tilemap

I tried a few automatic layout approaches but:

In addition I wanted to include Māori electorates in the same make which broke many algorithms

I spent a lot of time looking at the General Electorates and Māori Elecotorates and lining up the tilemaps

electorates

And then sending the map to various people who hadn't seen it to get first impressions

Aside: Corners for previous results

The 2020 tilemap was an evolution of our 2017 ones

old tiles

Interestingly it wasn't until we incorporated the corner triangles that showed the previous result that readers got really enthusistic about the tilemap

Other Features: Zoom and Support

Regional Zoom

zoom

Sort by ??

sort

Who's in and Who's Out?

  • Prior to the election it seemed likely that their would be a big change in who's in parliament
  • We wanted to make easy to get from the numbers to who was actually in parliament - which isn't always straight-forward under MMP

Keith Ng

Visualisation Implementation

  • Small components and tilemap implemented in Svelte

  • Who's in who's out and detailled parliament implement in D3

d3

Questions

© 2019–20 by Chris Knox. All rights reserved.
Last build: 2020-11-25